Technology

Synthetic Biology's Dirty Secret: Escaped Organisms

Genetic engineering is not a silver bullet to fix waste issues. There are serious concerns that warrant a closer look.

Synthetic Biology's Dirty Secret: Escaped Organisms
Refill of liquid on tubes, Louis Reed
SHARE:

Waste is a significant issue worldwide. You can see the evidence everywhere, from overflowing landfills to plastics in the ocean. Scientists are seeking ways to reduce waste production and manage the accumulation. Synthetic biology may hold the answer, as scientists are developing microbes to degrade waste products. However, the threat of escaped organisms to the ecosystem is a significant concern.

Water drops on a surface, Solen Feyissa
Water drops on a surface, Solen Feyissa

Lab-Created Microbes in Waste Processing Facilities

Waste processing facilities are full of non-degradable waste. They are one of the few places that handle it, as the necessary infrastructure is often lacking in many places. Within the waste are metals from microchips and other technology. Natural microbes slowly break down metals and other harsh pollutants. However, bioengineered microbes can degrade these materials faster. They can also create healthy soil, clean water and become functional proteins.

SUPPORTED BY ECO REBELS LIKE YOU

Support independent eco journalism that drives real change.
JOIN US →

Some microbes have the natural ability to consume harmful materials. For example, scientists discovered a microbe called Ideonella in 2001 that naturally consumes plastic. Now, they aim to genetically modify it to eliminate plastic waste more efficiently. Microbes like these need assistance from lab professionals to have a positive impact on the environment.

Other lab-created microbes can degrade hydrocarbons on oil sites, which is a massive form of waste outside of processing facilities. Oil spills create long-lasting negative impacts on the environment and human health. Further research could significantly mitigate these effects.

Waste is a huge issue. In the United States, people waste 92 billion pounds of food annually, which accounts for 51.7% of total waste. Synthetic biology companies are seeking ways to address this issue. Lab-created microbes are often more efficient than natural microbes, so implementing them into waste processing facilities might be the next step. However, they may pose unnecessary risks to the ecosystem.

Ecological Consequences of Escaped Organisms

Since lab-created microbes do not originate from the ecosystem, their introduction can potentially harm it. One risk is horizontal gene transfer, where microbes exchange genetic material with each other. A natural microbe could transfer genes to the lab-created one, potentially rendering its engineered function ineffective. 

Conversely, the lab-created microbe could pass its artificial genes to a natural one. This would pollute the ecosystem with an unfamiliar, modified species. If an organism ingests or comes into contact with the lab-created microbe, it could mutate into a new breed. 

Without proper isolation, the new organism could harm the ecosystem in unforeseen ways. For instance, while the lab-created microbe destroys pollutants, it may also harm other organisms. It could also take resources from different species, leaving them to starve. 

Scientists have not conducted enough tests to introduce lab-created microbes into the real world, so they cannot assess their potential damages or advantages accurately yet. Without knowing the actual cost, releasing organisms into the wild is not a viable option.

Possible Solutions for Escaped Organisms

While there are risks to introducing lab-created microbes, some solutions do exist. Scientists can program microbes to die after they consume a pollutant. This approach would limit their impact on the local ecosystem if executed correctly.

Scientists can also limit the risk of horizontal gene transfer by inducing cell lysis , breaking down the microbe until it is no longer intact. The possibility of destroying all of the microbes in the process is slim, but keeping them contained limits this risk.

The Future of Synthetic Waste Management

The process of degrading waste in facilities that use lab-created microbes is still largely unknown and untested. Synthetic biology is a complex field with numerous unexplored areas. The regulations that limit the use of lab-created microbes are inadequate because scientists lack sufficient knowledge to establish proper guidelines. New risk assessments that consider microbes would help scientists learn more about them safely.

Limiting waste is a significant step toward a greener future. Using a microbe, even a lab-created one, is a more natural method compared to incineration or landfills, which pollute the earth and damage the surrounding ecosystem. Scientists are continually seeking environmentally safe solutions to address climate change. Waste facilities could utilize microbes to aid in the process, as long as scientists handle escaped organisms safely.

From Dirty Secret to Sustainable Solution

While lab-created microbes pose a complex risk to the world’s ecosystem, they also offer potential solutions to the waste problem. This research is critical because the decisions made in labs today will shape the health of the ecosystem that you and future generations will depend on. To mitigate risks, scientists must conduct additional tests to determine the potential effects of microbes and assess whether they are a sustainable solution for reducing waste.

Don't let this fire die when you close the tab.

You just read Synthetic Biology's Dirty Secret: Escaped Organisms.
Now join the people actually doing it.

Every week you'll get:

  • One dead-simple Nudge that saves money + cuts CO₂
  • Monthly Swap challenge with accountability buddies
  • Ad-free site + early access + private community

First 150 members lock in lowest price forever + get the printed manifesto shipped free.

YES, MAKE ME AN ECO-REBEL → Not yet – show me another article